Editorial: Smartphone users have it good By: Anthony Newman, Friday 16th January 2004, 10:46 GMT
Windows Mobile Editor Anthony Newman has spent some time with a normal mobile phone, and finds that while things have come a long way, there's a lot left to do.
As a technology writer, I'm continually exposed to the latest gadgets. My main phones
over the recent past have been smartphones and connected handhelds, from the O2
XDA through to the latest Treo 600 and SPV E200. However, I recently decided to
investigate what was going on back in the 'normal' world of communication, and got
myself a mobile phone - nothing more, nothing less. Although it's by no means dumb, it's
not smart either, and this set me thinking about how the two categories could learn from
each other.
Mobile phones are drawing closer to smartphones, it has to be said. The latest handsets
are loaded with high-resolution colour screens, proper audio capabilities, PIM suites, full
e-mail support, add-on applications via Java, full connectivity through Bluetooth and
media capabilities through cameras. In fact, the line is pretty blurred.
However, the biggest thing that mobiles have still to learn from smartphones comes in
customization. With the majority of mobile phones there's no today screen concept
familiar from Microsoft's offerings, nor can the menu structure be reconfigured to better
match personal usage. Things remain as the manufacturer, not the user, intended. This
means wasted button presses and frustrated users.
Phones also leave a lot to be desired in terms of sheer power and storage. The lack of
card slots, MP3 players, document viewers and all those gubbins mean that all that extra
functionality is annoyingly missing, with no option of adding it through third-party
applications. Those applications that are present remain anaemic, too: one won't find a
phone capable of synchronizing your e-mail from a desktop. In fact, synchronization as a
whole remains a mess of proprietary programs and data cables for most phones. I never
thought I'd praise ActiveSync, but here I am missing it.
However, smartphones have a few things to learn too. They still can't come close to the
svelte beauty and pocketable size of modern mobile phones, and nor do their battery lives
match the week-long duration of some plainer offerings.
Finally, although Handspring have cracked a lot of things with their Treo 600, there are
few other smartphones and connected handhelds that can match the most basic Nokia for
speed and efficiency in the everyday, common tasks (such as messaging), and their sheer
brick-like solidity under daily punishment.
So, what we need is a simple, powerful, small, fast, usable, customizable and expandable
handset with an eternal battery life. Sounds impossible? I'm not giving up hope just yet.
Sony Ericsson Z600 Sony Ericsson's new Z600 clamshell boasts a 16-bit colour screen, integrated camera and Bluetooth - all at a comfortable price. Find out what Sindre Lia has to say about it.
Nokia 7200 The dual-band GSM Nokia 7200 is Nokia's first clamshell handset with an integrated digital camera, accompanied by Wireless Village instant messaging and an FM radio.
Nokia 7700 Based on Symbian OS and Nokia's own Series 90 platform, the Nokia 7700 features a high-resolution, landscape touchscreen and a vast range of advanced technologies.